FeedBack

Positive Feedback vs. Negative Feedback

Feedback is a process where a portion of the output of a system is fed back into the input. Feedback mechanisms are crucial in controlling the behavior of systems, especially in amplifiers, oscillators, and control systems. There are two main types of feedback: positive feedback and negative feedback.

1. Positive Feedback

In positive feedback, the feedback signal is in phase with the input signal, which means that the feedback adds to the input signal, reinforcing it. Essentially, the output is fed back in such a way that it increases the effect of the input signal.

Mechanism:

• The feedback signal increases the input to the system, causing a larger output, which in turn increases the feedback signal even more.

• In amplifiers, positive feedback can lead to an unstable increase in output, and in extreme cases, it can cause saturation or oscillation (as seen in relaxation oscillators or some types of regenerative circuits).

Example:

• Oscillators: In electronic oscillators, positive feedback is used to sustain oscillations. Without it, the signal would eventually die out. The positive feedback ensures that the output continuously regenerates itself.

Advantages of Positive Feedback:

1. Increased Gain: Positive feedback can be used to increase the overall gain of a system, such as in amplifiers or oscillators.

2. Oscillation: It is necessary for generating oscillations in circuits like signal generators or clocks.

3. Signal Amplification: Can be used to amplify weak signals in certain applications.

4. Quicker Response Time: In some systems, positive feedback can cause a faster transition between states (for example, in flip-flops or Schmitt triggers).

Disadvantages of Positive Feedback:

1. Instability: Positive feedback can make a system unstable, potentially leading to uncontrolled growth of the output. In amplifiers, this can result in distortion, or in worse cases, saturation (the output reaches its maximum or minimum value and cannot increase any further).

2. Oscillation: If not controlled properly, positive feedback can lead to unwanted oscillations, as seen in regenerative circuits, leading to noise or instability.

3. Non-linearity: Positive feedback can lead to non-linearities in the system, making it harder to control or predict the system behavior.

4. Reduced Accuracy: For most linear applications (like amplifiers), positive feedback can degrade the accuracy and linearity of the output signal.

2. Negative Feedback

In negative feedback, the feedback signal is opposite (or out of phase) to the input signal, which means that the feedback reduces the effect of the input. The output signal is fed back in such a way that it opposes the input, stabilizing the system.

Mechanism:

• Negative feedback works by reducing the discrepancy between the input and output. It stabilizes the system by decreasing the gain and making the system’s behavior more predictable.

• In amplifiers, negative feedback reduces distortion, improves bandwidth, and increases linearity by counteracting variations in the system’s gain or performance.

Example:

• Operational Amplifiers (Op-Amps): Negative feedback is commonly used in op-amps to stabilize the gain and prevent distortion. The op-amp uses the output to control the input in such a way that the difference between the two inputs remains minimal.

Advantages of Negative Feedback:

1. Stability: Negative feedback helps to stabilize the system and prevent the gain from becoming too high, avoiding saturation and oscillations.

2. Improved Linearity: By reducing the effect of non-linearities in the circuit, negative feedback can provide more accurate, linear amplification.

3. Reduced Distortion: Negative feedback reduces harmonic distortion in amplifiers, making the output signal more faithful to the input.

4. Constant Gain: Negative feedback helps maintain a constant gain over a wide range of operating conditions, such as changes in temperature, supply voltage, or load conditions.

5. Increased Bandwidth: In amplifiers, negative feedback can extend the bandwidth by reducing the gain, which allows for more stable performance across a wide frequency range.

6. Reduced Sensitivity to Component Variations: It minimizes the impact of variations in the circuit components, such as resistors or transistors, thus improving overall system performance.

Disadvantages of Negative Feedback:

1. Reduced Gain: Negative feedback reduces the overall gain of the system. For high-gain applications, the use of negative feedback may require additional amplification stages to compensate.

2. Complexity: Implementing negative feedback in a circuit might require more complex circuitry to ensure that the feedback is properly managed, which can increase design complexity and cost.

3. Slower Response: In some systems, negative feedback can cause a slower response time since it introduces a stabilizing factor that can dampen rapid changes.

4. Risk of Over-compensation: If not carefully designed, negative feedback can lead to over-compensation, where the system’s response becomes sluggish or even unstable, similar to how overdamping can affect mechanical systems.

---

Summary of Differences:

Aspect	Positive Feedback	Negative Feedback
Effect on Output	Amplifies or reinforces the output signal	Reduces or stabilizes the output signal
System Behavior	Can lead to instability, oscillation, or saturation	Leads to stable, predictable behavior
Gain	Can increase gain but often at the cost of stability	Reduces gain but improves stability and accuracy
Applications	Used in oscillators, regenerative circuits, certain amplifiers	Used in linear amplifiers, control systems, op-amps
Advantages	Fast response, oscillation, increased gain in some cases	Stability, reduced distortion, constant gain, wider bandwidth
Disadvantages	Instability, oscillations, non-linearity, reduced accuracy	Reduced gain, complexity, slower response, over-compensation

Conclusion

• Positive feedback is mainly used in applications that require regenerative behavior, such as oscillators and certain types of amplifiers. While it can provide fast response and increased gain, it has the downside of making systems unstable and prone to oscillation.

• Negative feedback, on the other hand, is used to stabilize systems and improve the accuracy and linearity of amplifiers and other systems, at the cost of reduced gain. It is essential in most linear electronic circuits, ensuring that the system behaves predictably and consistently.